Wondering which baby items are worth buying new vs used in Canada?
Raising a baby comes with plenty of decisions — from choosing the right stroller to figuring out what really needs to be brand-new versus what you can save money on by buying second-hand. For many Canadian parents, balancing safety, value, and practicality means knowing when it's okay to go used and when you should stick to new.
Here's a helpful guide to baby gear new vs. used, what most families consider safe to buy second-hand, and when it's smarter to invest in new items. And for more ways to save big on baby products, check out our guide to the best free baby samples in Canada!
Why Buying Second-Hand Makes Sense for Many Families
Babies grow fast — often outgrowing clothing, swings, and toys before they've barely worn them. That's why many parents turn to second-hand options: consignment stores, online marketplaces, Facebook Buy Nothing groups, and local community swaps. These places can be a treasure trove of gently used items at a fraction of the cost of new ones.
Plus, buying used can help reduce waste and give products a second life, which appeals to many eco-minded Canadian families.
Items Often Bought Used (and Why They Work)
Baby Clothes and Soft Goods
Infants grow out of clothes so quickly that many pieces are barely worn. Clothing, blankets, and soft linens are great candidates for second-hand purchases — just make sure they're clean, free of stains, and safe for baby.
Toys, Books, and Play Mats
Toys and books can usually be bought used as long as they're not broken, missing parts, or recalled. Always clean items thoroughly and inspect them for safety before giving them to your child.
High Chairs, Dressers, and Furniture
Large pieces like high chairs, changing tables, or sturdy nursery furniture can be great used finds — especially if you can confirm they meet current safety standards and aren't recalled. As with clothing and toys, cleaning and inspecting used furniture is essential.
Items That Are Best Bought New
While used gear offers savings, some items are safer and more reliable when purchased new — especially when safety standards or wear matters:
Car Seats
Even Canada's safety authorities recommend caution with second-hand car seats, because you may not know the full history — including whether it's been in a collision, has expired, or is missing parts. Car seats must meet current Canadian safety regulations, and new ones come with clear instructions and registration for recall alerts.
According to the Health Canada information on second-hand car seats, any used child seat should have a National Safety Mark, be free of recalls, and include all original parts — conditions that are hard to verify with many used seats.
Cribs and Crib Mattresses
Health Canada notes that new cribs, cradles, and bassinets must meet current safety standards for safe sleep, and older or recalled models can be hazardous. Crib mattresses should also be new to ensure they fit snugly and meet current safe sleep recommendations.
Feeding Supplies
Items like bottles, nipples, pacifiers, and breast pump parts are best bought new for hygiene reasons — they come sealed and designed for single-user use.
When Used Might Be Okay — With Care
Some parents choose used versions of products that aren't directly safety-critical, as long as they're in excellent condition and can be inspected thoroughly:
- Baby carriers and wraps (inspect buckles and fabric)
- Bouncers and swings (if all parts and instructions are intact)
- Strollers (check brakes, straps, and joints)
- Nursery decor (pictures, rugs, shelves)
Many families have successfully found these second-hand while avoiding unnecessary expense, especially for items that don't have expiration dates or safety standards tied to impact protection. Learn more on BabyCenter.
Tips for Safe Second-Hand Purchases
Whether you're browsing consignment shops, online marketplaces, or your local Buy Nothing group:
- Check for recalls before buying any baby product, new or used.
- Inspect condition thoroughly — no cracks, tears, missing pieces, or rust.
- Ask for manuals or instructions when possible.
- Clean everything well before use.
- Know which items should always be new (see above).
You can learn more about choosing safe second-hand products and tips from Health Canada's guide to buying second-hand, including what to avoid and how to check safety compliance.
Finding Deals While Still Staying Safe
Even when buying new, savvy parents take advantage of:
- Coupons and discount offers (check our Baby Coupons Canada page)
- Free samples and product trials
- Giveaways to save on big purchases
- Registry completion discounts
- Seasonal sales and loyalty programs
This way you balance safety and savings — especially in the early expensive months of parenthood.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buying Baby Items New vs Used
What baby items should always be bought new?
Car seats, cribs, crib mattresses, bottle nipples, pacifiers, and breast pump parts should always be bought new. These items are closely tied to safety, hygiene, and current Canadian regulations.
Is it safe to buy second-hand baby clothes and toys?
Yes, baby clothes, books, and toys are generally safe to buy second-hand as long as they're clean, in good condition, and not subject to a product recall. Always inspect items carefully before use.
Can I use a second-hand car seat if it looks fine?
Health Canada advises caution with second-hand car seats because it's difficult to verify their full history, including whether they've been in an accident, expired, or recalled. If you can't confirm all details, it's safer to buy new.
What should I check before buying used baby gear?
Check for recalls, missing parts, damage, proper labeling, and current safety standards. If instructions are missing or the product looks worn or altered, it's best to skip it.
Why do so many parents choose second-hand baby items?
Babies outgrow items quickly, making second-hand gear a practical and budget-friendly option. Many parents also appreciate the environmental benefits of reusing baby products.
Final Thoughts
There's no one-size-fits-all answer to new vs. used baby gear. Many items — like clothing, toys, and furniture — can be safely bought second-hand, while safety-critical gear such as car seats and sleep surfaces are best bought new to meet modern standards and reduce risk.
As a Canadian parent, weighing your budget, safety guidelines, and product quality will help you make the smartest choices for your family — and save money where it makes sense.
This post is also available in: Français (French)